UW Press




FaceBook Twitter Tumblr GoodReads UW Press Newsletter







UW Madison

American Association of University Presses



Home / Books

A Passion to Preserve
Gay Men as Keepers of Culture
Will Fellows

Contents | Preface | Individuals Profiled | Reviews | Events | Author |


Preface ix

Charlotte and Me:
Preservation-Minded from Childhood 3
­ Will Fellows
­ Charlotte von Mahlsdorf

In Search of Gay Preservationists 13

What These Gay Men's Lives Reveal 25

Saving Old New England
Introduction 37
-- William Bentley
-- Henry David Thoreau
-- Cummings Elsthan Davis
-- Henry Davis Sleeper
-- William Sumner Appleton
-- Ralph Adams Cram
-- Charles Hammond Gibson
-- Allen Young
Mark Doty 44
Don Leavitt 50
Mark Sammons 53

Design-Minded in the Mid-Atlantic States
Introduction 57
-- Henry Chapman Mercer
-- James Denholm Van Trump
-- Joseph Svehlak
Ken Lustbader 61
James Nocito 65
Dwight Young 69
Greg Kinsman 73

To the Rescue in the Atlantic South
Introduction 79
-- Jim Williams
-- Jack Richards
-- Bob Page
-- Jerry Herman and Marty Finkelstein
Allan Gurganus 84
Myrick Howard 90
John Anders 95
Robert Barker 99
Cranford Sutton 103

Domophiles out West
Introduction 107
-- Larry Kreisman
-- Cliff Schlothauer
-- Robert Frost and Ralph Bolton
Jay Yost 111
Ken Miller 116
Gilbert Millikan and David Richards 121
Richard Jost and Charles Fuchs 125

California Conservative
Introduction 131
-- Roy Little and Jim Raidl
-- Lee Liberace
-- Kent Warner
-- Jeffrey Shorn and Charles Kaminski
Richard Reutlinger 138
Gerry Takano 147
Jeffrey Samudio 150
Jim Wilke 156

Generations of Gentlemen Keep Cooksville, Wisconsin
Introduction 161
-- Ralph Warner
-- Chester Holway and Marvin Raney
-- Elton Breckenridge
-- Eric Lieber (pseudonym)
-- Michael Saternus
William Wartmann 174
Al Garland (pseudonym) 182
Larry Reed 186

Singular Preservationists in the Midwest
Introduction 191
-- Robert Neal and Edgar Hellum
-- Richard Nickel
-- Alex Davidson (pseudonym)
Dana Duppler 204
Joe Johnson and Ron Markwell 211
Robert Seger 214

Cherishing Old New Orleans and Louisiana
Introduction 217
-- Allison Owen
-- William Irby
-- Richard Koch
-- Arnold Genthe
-- Lyle Saxon
-- William Spratling
-- Weeks Hall
-- Harnett Kane
-- Boyd Cruise
-- Clay Shaw
-- Roberts Batson
-- Don Schueler
Curt Greska (pseudonym) 230
Lloyd Sensat 235
Randy Plaisance 239

Toward a Larger View of Gay Men 243

Conclusion 259

Acknowledgments 265

Notes 267

Index 282


It may seem unlikely that a book about gay men as keepers of culture would be inspired by a book about gays growing up among cows and corn fields, but that's what happened. In creating my first book, Farm Boys, I immersed myself in the life stories of gay men who grew up in farm families. I had long suspected that my own rural upbringing exerted a lasting influence on how I lived my life as a gay man. It seemed that getting other gay men from similar backgrounds to tell me about their lives would serve as a lens through which I might gain some insight into my own life. So I traveled around the Midwest one year doing autobiographical interviews.

Gender-role nonconformity was prominent in many of those Farm Boys interviews: As boys, most of the men I spoke with had been especially drawn to doing things that lay outside the range of activities approved for males. Instead of working in the fields or repairing farm machinery, they preferred doing things in and around the house, and were often very good at them: gardening, cooking, food-canning, flower-arranging, decorating, sewing and other needlework. At first, I was bothered by this strong gender-atypical trend; I assumed it was the result of a pervasive bias in my self-selected group of interview subjects. There must be plenty of gay men out there who were regular, gender-typical farm boys, I thought: Perhaps the atypical ones are simply more inclined to talk about their lives. Maybe the regular guys just aren't sufficiently chatty or insightful or out of the closet to want to do this sort of interview.

Then, as it eventually occurred to me that what I was seeing was perhaps characteristic of gay childhood, this trend toward gender-atypicality began to intrigue me. For one thing, it mirrored my own childhood. And it was at odds with the old saw about gay males being no different from straight males except for their sexual orientation. This notion developed as a central tenet of the gay rights movement since the 1970s, the decade in which I came of age and came out, when gay men in America went macho in their self-presentation: "We're men, first and foremost; regular guys who just happen to prefer guys." All of this led me to wonder: If we differ from straight men only in terms of sexual orientation, not in any other essential ways, why was I discovering this preponderance of gay men who had been manifestly queer since childhood, usually years before their sex lives got going? In the years since Farm Boys was published, the responses I've had from readers have consistently affirmed the book's gender-atypical portrait.

The extraordinary and pioneering involvement of gay men in historic preservation is something of which I've long been at least vaguely aware. Though I paid little attention to it at the time, many of the men I interviewed for Farm Boys engaged in some sort of culture-keeping: they lived in restored older houses, often furnished and decorated with antiques, many of them family heirlooms; they compiled information and objects related to family heritage and local history. I didn't ask them specifically about these interests; they were simply evident in one way or another.

Only since completing Farm Boys have I considered gays-in-preservation a phenomenon worthy of exploration. To the limited extent that I gave it even a passing thought in earlier years, I suppose I saw the apparently disproportionate presence of gay men in historic preservation as the stuff of stereotype. And so I failed to take it seriously. If outside of our sex lives we gays are just like straights, then it must be only a stereotypical illusion that gay men are inordinately drawn to being house restorers and antiquarians - or interior designers, florists, hair stylists, fashion designers, and so forth. Now it's clear to me that gay men really are extraordinarily attracted to these kinds of work. Rather than dismissing these realities as the stuff of stereotype, I see them as the stuff of archetype, significant truths worthy of exploration. Gay men are a prominent and highly talented presence in many female-dominated fields that revolve around creating, restoring, and preserving beauty, order, and continuity. It's a phenomenon that seems to grow out of an essential gay difference.

In his book about why so many gay men love musical theater, John Clum hints at this essential differentness: "For me, being gay has as much to do with an investment in certain kinds of culture as it has with my sexual proclivities." (1) Gay rights pioneer Harry Hay goes further, saying that we gay men "must disenthrall ourselves of the idea that we differ only in our sexual directions, and that all we want or need in life is to be free to seek the expression of our sexual desires as we see fit." (2 ) Gay men as keepers of culture proves to be a powerful lens through which to examine some of the distinctive dimensions of gay male lives beyond sexuality per se. (3) With this book, I hope to add my small lamp to a fuller illumination of what it means to be gay.

1 John M. Clum, Something for the Boys: Musical Theater and Gay Culture. (New York: Palgrave, 1999), 19.

2 Harry Hay, Radically Gay: Gay Liberation in the Words of Its Founder, ed. Will Roscoe (Boston: Beacon, 1996), 53.

3 For the phrase "keepers of culture" I credit Clyde Hall, a gay American Indian who uses those words to describe the role that he and other males like him have always played in the life of his tribe. Mark Thompson, Gay Soul: Finding the Heart of Gay Spirit and Nature (New York: HarperCollins, 1995), 125.


"'Real men build. They don't fix up.' So says an architect quoted in Will Fellows's terrific A Passion to Preserve. Fellows's research illustrates how gay men's efforts to 'fix up' have played a crucial role in the preservation and revitalization of many of America's greatest urban neighborhoods. A Passion to Preserve provides a rich and detailed examination of an important and heretofore neglected aspect of our urban heritage." — Richard Florida, author of The Rise of the Creative Class

"Clearly Will Fellows has hit a nerve with many gay men, and many of them write about their collecting and preserving, from childhood on, often sacrificing friends, livelihoods, careers, and lovers to do so. As with his previous book, Farm Boys, Fellows presents the material in people's own voices as much as possible and the best of these essays (and there are many) are wonderfully readable capsule biographies and histories."
—Darden Asbury Pyron, author of Liberace: An American Boy

"The main strength of the project is the actual oral histories recorded here by the editor. Fellows is a wonderful preservationist himself; the book's impressive range of contributors speaks to the care and skill he brings to his work." —David Román, professor of English and American Studies, University of Southern California


Will Fellows, 1974
"While many boys my age got into sports, hunting, cars, and girls, I rode the school bus home to chum with Grandma and my old-fashioned things. I hung out the open sign near the highway in front of my antique shop.... Wearing the key to my shop around my neck, I was always ready for business, though I might be doing farm chores, mowing the lawn, or working in the vegetable garden.... My attraction to the antiques trade was not entirely undivided, though: I sometimes found it difficult to tear my eyes away from the sweaty, muscular hired hands...." —Will Fellows, from A Passion to Preserve.

Will Fellows, 2004
Will Fellows is the author of Farm Boys: Lives of Gay Men from the Rural Midwest, a finalist for the Lambda Literary Award in 1997. Farm Boys was recognized as a notable book of 1996 by Esquire and the Minneapolis Star Tribune. It was lauded as a bestseller by The Advocate, Lambda Book Report, and InsightOut Book Club. A writer and educator, Will Fellows lives with his partner in Milwaukee. As Fellows explains in the book's preface, his decision to research and write A Passion to Preserve grew out of his own lifelong penchant for historic preservation, and was informed by insights gained while writing Farm Boys. Photo by Ellen Cook.

For more information about Farm Boys

To contact the author, email passiontopreserve@hotmail.com

Media & bookseller inquiries regarding review copies, events, and interviews can be directed to the publicity department at publicity@uwpress.wisc.edu or (608) 263-0734. (If you want to examine a book for possible course use, please see our Course Books page. If you want to examine a book for possible rights licensing, please see Rights & Permissions.)